Thursday, July 14, 2011

Landfill Litter Blog Readers

Since starting this blog last February, I have seen a steady increase in readers.  Blogspot lets the author look up stats for the number of hits per day, per month and all time.  The number of hits last month was 104, and this month, the number of hits on this landfill litter blog will certainly exceed that if the trend continues.   Halfway through the month of July, the number of hits is just slightly below the total for the month of June.

More interesting to me is who's going onto this blog.  Blogspot also gives you location by country.  here's the list so far (in alphabetical order)

  • Australia
  • Brunei
  • Canada
  • Germany
  • India
  • Kenya
  • Malaysia
  • New Zealand
  • Romania
  • Switzerland
  • Ukraine
  • United Kingdom
  • United States
Thanks to all of you who have taken the time to read my blog on landfill litter.  I hope that I'm able to achieve my objective of passing along what I have learned in my 30 years that I've worked in this field.  

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Great Pacific Ocean Garbage Patch

In the north Pacific Ocean, the ocean currents circulate in what is known as the Pacific Gyre.   In the past few years there have been reports of discarded plastics and debris circulating in this gyre is such mass that it has created "another continent".  At least that's one description I came across.  A more common description that is out there, and one that was also reported by Oprah (and by the way, I am not a fan of Oprah), that this garbage mass is the size of Texas and is 90 feet deep.  Certainly if you google the Pacific Ocean Garbage Patch, you'll easily find numerous web pages with these kinds of descriptions.   Most are on environmental web pages, some of which are designed to shock you. 

Then you'll also find other descriptions by scientific researchers who don't deny the gathering of plastic, but they counter the claims of the 8th continent being formed by garbage.   They certainly have reported the evidence of garbage and bits of plastic floating in the ocean currents and in what appears to be alarming amounts.  But it hasn't formed an island the size of Texas.  

You'll find photos on a few web pages that seem to support the claim of this floating Island.  My question is, where are these photos taken.  You'll see photos of animals caught up in plastic netting and a turtle that had a plastic ring around when it was young and the story of how it grew into a deformed adult.  Oprah shows that one.  So did these animals really get caught up in this whirlpool of floating garbage, or did they get it from along the shore lines of the Pacific.  I think that there are exaggerated claims to shock and make a point.   Some of this might be true, some of it isn't.  


You can go onto google and You Tube and read up on this story yourself and look at the videos.  Once you get on line, you'll find more and more and more stories and you tube videos.    Try to look at all sides of this story and draw your own conclusions.   (Links below)


But, here's what I believe.  Based on what I've read and seen in a few videos, I believe there is an issue with floating debris and plastic in the Pacific Ocean.  It likely does get caught up in this gyre.  If there is that much floating plastic in the Pacific, surely there is a similar problem in our other oceans.   I DON"T believe in the garbage island the size of Texas or the formation of the 8th continent.  The videos I looked at made by folks who were there certainly DON'T show any island or continent.  And by the way, those folks who describe it as a continent should read up on plate tectonics and find out what a continent actually is before using that description.   The videos DO show floating debris and plastics, and that should be a great concern to us.  It truly is an example of the impact we humans are having on this planet.  http://youtu.be/ISaGrlpK2zE
http://youtu.be/ISaGrlpK2zE
http://youtu.be/y5y1W5xduiE
http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/environment/2009-08-28-pacific-garbage-patch_N.htm
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/earthnews/8241265/Great-Garbage-Patch-in-the-Pacific-Ocean-not-so-great-claim-scientists.html

Here is a photo that I came across on a few web pages.  This shows a chap in a canoe paddling through floating garbage.  So where is the picture actually taken?  I could not find the original source or photographer name.  Is it taken out in the middle of the Pacific on this "garbage island".  Often the text that goes with this photo suggests that.  But, would someone really be out in the middle of the Pacific Ocean in a canoe?  Or was this picture taken somewhere close to shore? Perhaps at some location where garbage is dumped over the shore into the ocean?  Hey, that still happens in some parts of the world.    I won't deny the photograph is real.  It also is quite a graphic display of a horrendous and shameful waste disposal practice.  I would just like to know the true location where this photo was taken. 

I will say with certainty what I know.   I don't know what the real truth is on this topic.  The only way I will be able to know with certainty of this floating garbage story, is that I will have to get in a boat and go look for myself.  


http://youtu.be/ISaGrlpK2zEhttp://youtu.be/ISaGrlpK2zE
http://youtu.be/y5y1W5xduiE

Monday, July 4, 2011

Old Photos

I was going through some old computer photo files today.  I came across some photographs I took on a cold winter day a few years ago at the Newell Regional Landfill.  I thought I'd share these photos with you. 

First thing you'll notice, it is cold and the landfill is snow covered.  A good snowfall can make a landfill look pretty and clean.  Snow is a real good at covering up litter.  That is, until spring when it melts.  That's why a spring clean up of landfills in our part of world is always scheduled in the operating plan. 

The second thing you should notice in these pictures is the litter fences around the active working face.  This isn't the most effective configuration of these fences.  I have been at this site when the operators have completely encircled the working face with the portable fences. 

They lay the fences out in a kind of spiral so that there is an opening for access for the inbound customers.   This gives complete coverage for litter control in all directions.  At this location, winds direction can change quickly, so this kind of fence layout has shown to be effective. 


The third thing you should notice is the small working face.   This landfill isn't a particularly large operation, but never-the-less, they do put the effort in to keep the working face small to limit exposure of waste to the wind. 


The portable fences used at this site include a combination of litter catchment fences and wind screen fences. The fences are designed with a sloping face for better trapment of the litter.  The wind screens shelter the working face to reduce the wind speed. 




Sunday, July 3, 2011

Landfill Impact Assessment

I was just reading Landfill Impact Assessment report.  The report went to great lengths evaluating dust, noise, landfill gas, and odours.  It included a brief discussion on litter impact.  The study effort included a great deal of work using dispersion models that used climate and wind data, topography and so on to determine what impact, if any, there would be on nearby receptors.   The authors took great efforts to determine waste quantities for the next 35 years, modelled landfill gas emissions, conducted traffic flow assessments, and measured odour emissions from the existing landfill



The Blowing Litter Impact Assessment reported the following information:


Distance from landfill perimeter
Finding
Impact category
0 - 500m
50% of escaping litter remains in this area
Medium
500 – 1000 m
Remaining 50% retained in this area
Low
Beyond 1000 m
Very little escapes beyond this distance
None




This information was said to have been taken from a 'previous report' by RWDI (2002).  I did an internet search in an attempt to find the original source of this information, but was unsuccessful (so far).  I could not determine if this referenced report was related to the existing landfill at this location.  


A second table that was referenced to RWDI (2002) is said to be a study conducted in wind tunnels on "threshold speeds for various categories of wind-blown litter".   Again, I tried to find the original source of this information, so I don't know how this study was done.  Did it replicate waste in a pile, or did it replicate waste dropping from an unloading vehicle?  I would assume that we would see different results between the two scenarios. 


Wind speed range
Litter description
Impact category
0 – 22 km/h
No blowing litter
None
22 – 33 km/h
Newsprint, tissue, paper towel, some light bond paper
Light
33 – 47 km/h
All the above plus plastic bags, small boxes, small cardboard tubes, paper bags, plastic sheets.
Moderate
Above 47 km/h
All the above plus extensive heavy bond paper
heavy



The authors of the report suggested that the average annual wind speed 10 metres above the ground is 8.6 km/hr, and that it would be about 2.3 km/hr at the 2 metre level.  The authors then concluded that for the majority of wind velocities at the landfill, blowing litter would not occur.  This conclusion was based on the following table.

Table L2.34 - Frequency of Occurrence of Blowing Litter with Wind Speed

Speed range
km/h

Annual frequency (%)

0 – 22

94.0

22 – 33

5.8

33 – 47

0.2

47+

<0.1



One can see if you connect all the dots using this information, you would come to a similar conclusion.    The authors further concluded that because most of the landfill operations will be below ground, this would further reduce wind-blown litter.   Recommendations suggested the litter mitigation should include, covering waste haul vehicles, daily cover of the working face, portable wind fences, improving vegetated lands buffering the landfill, educate the public about plastic bags, regular inspections and litter clean up. 


This evaluation is probably fairly typical of impact assessment studies. Litter issues usually don't get the same level of effort as other 'emissions' from landfills, even though litter is probably the most visible immission.  This may be because it is assumed that litter controls are very basic, such as cover, fencing, and cleaning up, that there's little need to do a complete evaluation.  Granted, because litter is visible and accessible, it is easier to respond to that a groundwater or gaseous emission impact.   I do think that landfill planners and engineers do need to give more attention to litter control and prevention.  They usually leave that up to the landfill manager and operators.   


I will admit, there may be more information available on specific litter controls in detailed operation plans.  At this time, I don't have that information. 


You can see the original report by going to the following link. 


https://muskoka.civicweb.net/Documents/DocumentDisplay.aspx?ID=5002

Friday, July 1, 2011

Wind Patterns at Landfills

At a landfill, you have to deal with winds of different speeds and strength, steady winds, gusting winds, and winds that come from different directions.   The topography of your site affects the wind patterns at your site.  Know and understanding these winds and wind patterns is key to understanding how to properly apply your litter controls. 



Wind Over The Ground

Wind that blows over the ground creates a micro-pattern along the ground surface.  As the wind passes over the ground, the wind speed is slowed due to friction with the ground surface.  The type of vegetation and surface roughness will influence the degree of this effect.  For the most part, you would not notice this effect.

What is important to understand, is that smaller particles and easily airborne particles will stay suspended in the air.  Heavier particles will tend to flow across the ground until they are trapped by and object.


This can be seen by observing the materials that makes up the litter at different distances from the landfill operation.    

Wind Over Hills

Hills cause a variety of effects on wind as it passes over.  As the wind blows into the hill, it will tend to decrease in speed at the toe of the hill.  This is because a high pressure zone occurs on the windward side of the hill.  As the air mass moves up the hill slope, it will accelerate and will reach a maximum speed at the apex of the hill.   A low pressure zone will occur on the downwind side of the hill and a reduced wind speed may be observed.  

Turbulent winds may also show on the upwind and downwind sides of the hill depending on wind speed and the shape of the hill.  

In a landfill setting, these wind patters can be observed around stockpiles and fill areas.   Dust can be observed drifting off the crest of a soil stockpile and litter can often be observed circulating in the turbulent winds on the downwind side of stockpiles and fill slopes.   


Wind Funneling

In a geographic valley setting,  such as a mountain pass, wind that blows through the valley can accelerate.   The valley acts like a venturi tube.  As wind enters the valley it is compressed and increases in speed.  When the wind exits the valley, the air pressure decreases, but the exiting wind is at a much higher speed than when it entered the valley.   (look up Santa Anna Wind)

This same funneling effect can occur in a landfill setting where the wind is blowing parallel to an narrow open trench, or where it blows between two fill areas.  The effect of this funneling may not be easily observed as it's effect may be minimal in most cases. 

Topographic Exposure

The diagram at left shows an example topographic setting with perpendicular winds and parallel winds.  A active fill area with the greatest exposure to strong winds are shown red, while low exposure is shown in green.   A landfill operator should know where the highest topographical exposure area is at the landfill.  It will not be the same for all landfills and all wind situations. 


Observe the Wind

To develop an effective landfill litter management plan, the landfill manager should observe wind patterns on and around the landfill.  Observe winds around all topographical features, both mounds and open excavations.   Observe wind patters at different wind directions and speeds.   Measure the winds.  You can purchase hand held wind meters that you can use as you walk through the site.  Record the different wind speeds. 

Observe turbulent air patterns.  You can often see plastic film circulating in turbulent air.  You may also notice the wind speed recorded on your hand held wind meter is very erratic in highly turbulent air. 

Observe how the wind effects your active working face and tip area.  How is the litter wind blown, and where it goes to.   Take photographs and record what you observe.